Andrea Dick, on the other hand, is a fervent supporter of the former president Trump and thinks that he stole the election. Joe Biden is not her favourite politician, but that is only the beginning of it.
Home Scream Messages in New Jersey
The harsh slogans “Don’t Blame Me/I Voted for Trump” and “Don’t Blame Me/I Voted for Trump” are displayed on banners outside her New Jersey house.
Some people use a word that some people perceive to be exceedingly offensive, yet the Supreme Court found in the past that its use could not be outlawed only to protect those it offends.
Some of the flags, according to municipal officials, were in violation of an anti-obscene ordinance, but she refused to take them down. She is currently defying a judge’s order and threatening to sue to have it overturned on the grounds that it violates her First Amendment rights.
I will uphold my First Amendment rights in this matter “She said in a Monday interview.
This is only the most recent in a long line of instances when local government officials have had to strike a delicate balance between defending free speech and addressing concerns about language that some residents find offensive.
The banners, according to her 54-year-old mother Dick, were acquired earlier this year from Amazon and other retailers, but weren’t hung or displayed until Memorial Day at their Roselle Park home.
“Something must have gotten me agitated,” she said.
She mentioned that her property was close to a school and that some Roselle Park residents were worried about the language of the banners and the possibility that passing kids would see it.
Mayor Joseph Signorello III claimed he had submitted objections to the borough’s code enforcement officer even though no formal complaints had been made.
The 14,000-person hamlet of Roselle Park, which is about 40 minutes from Times Square, voted resoundingly in favour of Biden as their vice presidential candidate in November.
Democrat Signorello noted that it “is not about politics in any respect.” He claimed that if demonstrators’ signs expressed their opposition to Trump’s leadership in the same way, officials would have followed suit. “Decency is on the line.”
Judy Mack, the Roselle Park code enforcement officer, handed Dilascio a citation for violating the borough’s ban on the display of pornographic material.
Mack claimed that throughout her more than ten years as a code enforcer for Roselle Park, she had never used the ordinance. She had heard the complaints from the locals, but Signorello had not given her any particular instructions.
He said that he was only Performing his duties as Mack.
Dick was given a short window of time by Mack to take down the banners. She was issued a ticket to appear in court following her absence.
Bundy emphasised the proximity of Dick’s home to a school in his decision, claiming that there are “alternative routes for the defendant to communicate her excitement or disgust with particular political leaders.”
He claimed that when they pass the house every day, “elementary-age children are exposed to that word since they use profanity.”
Freedom of speech is not just an unqualified right, he said, thus this is not a political case.” It’s a language issue, to put it simply. “This regulation does not impose restrictions on political discourse.” (NJ.com reported on Bundy’s choice on Friday.)
Jarrid Kantor, the borough attorney for Roselle Park, praised the decision, saying that officials had been careful to avoid politicising the Dick’s banners and had instead concentrated on the potential harm they would cause children.
“We think he got it Just Perfect,” Kantor said.
Thomas Healy, a Seton Hall University law professor, disagreed. He has extensive knowledge of constitutional law.
Healy used a Supreme Court ruling from 1971, Cohen v. California, that addressed whether or not the word at issue in Dick’s case was obscene, to show that the word in question in Dick’s case did not qualify as obscene speech.
It is “hard to envisage a simpler case from a constitutional standpoint,” according to him, that Bundy’s judgement would be upheld, which would be “stunned.”
Healy said he was worried that the enforcement action had occurred after the mayor had raised concerns about the banners to the code enforcement officer, despite the fact that both the mayor and the code enforcement officer confirmed that Signorello had not issued any specific orders.
It doesn’t Look Good, Healy said in response.
Similar conflicts this year have also occurred in Long Island, New York; in Indiana; Tennessee; Connecticut; and about a half-drive hour’s south of Roselle Park, in Hazlet, New Jersey, Dick’s hometown.
Similar complaints were made about a banner that was put up by a Hazlet homeowner, according to Mayor Tara Clark.
According to Clark, officials visited the homeowner last month and asked him to take down the flag in accordance with an anti-nuisance rule, but they did not take any action to enforce this.